Here is a really good example of a scholary research critique written by a student in EDRS The student who submitted this paper last semester earned a on his critique. The content of the paper is right on track. A succint summary is provided in the first paragraph 4/27/ · This paper presents a critique of a qualitative research article titled: ‘Perceived support from healthcare practitioners among adults with type 2 diabetes’ (Oftedal et al, ) (appendix 1). To enable the critique of this article the Caldwell critiquing tool () will be utilized Table 1. Research questions - guidelines for critiquing a quantitative research study Elements influencing the beiievabiiity of the research Elements Writing styie Author Report titie Abstract Questions Is the report well written - concise, grammatically correct, avoid the
Critique of a Research Article Free Essay Example
Surely the article will be of good quality if it has made it through the peer-review process? Publication bias can occur when editors only accept manuscripts that have a bearing on the direction of their own research, or reject manuscripts with negative findings.
Additionally, not all peer reviewers have expert knowledge on certain subject matterswhich can introduce bias and sometimes a conflict of interest. Performing critique research paper own critical analysis of an article allows you to consider its value to you and to your workplace.
Critical evaluation is defined as a systematic way of considering the truthfulness of a piece of research, its results and how relevant and applicable they are. Considering the article under the following headings may be of some use:. You may be a better judge of this after reading the article, but the title should succinctly reflect the content of the work, stimulating readers' interest. Three to six keywords that encapsulate the main topics of the research will have been drawn from the body of the article.
Similar to a recipe, the description of materials and methods will allow others to replicate the study elsewhere if needed. It should both contain and justify the exact specifications of selection criteria, sample size, response rate and any statistics used. This will demonstrate how the study is capable of achieving its aims. Things to consider in this section are:. Results should be statistically analysed and presented in a way that an average reader of the journal will understand.
Graphs and tables should be clear and promote clarity of the text. Consider whether:. Negative results are just as relevant as research that produces positive critique research paper but as mentioned previously may be omitted in publication due to editorial bias, critique research paper.
This should show insight into the meaning and significance of critique research paper research findings. It should not introduce any new material, but should address how the aims of the study have been met.
The discussion should use previous research work and theoretical concepts as the context in which the new study can be interpreted. Any limitations of the study, including bias, should be clearly presented. You will need to evaluate whether the author has clearly interpreted the results of the study, or whether the results could be interpreted another way.
These should be clearly stated and will only be valid if the study was reliable, valid and used a representative sample size. There may also be recommendations for further research. These should be relevant to the study, be up to date, and should provide a comprehensive list of citations within the text. Undertaking a critique of a research article may seem challenging at first, but will help you to evaluate whether the article has relevance to your own practice and workplace.
Reading a single article can act as a springboard into researching the topic more widely and critique research paper in ensuring your nursing practice remains current and is supported by existing literature. Sarah Vogel specialises in producing well researched articles in the field of health and medicine. She has a BHlthSci MRThaving studied and worked as a Radiation Therapist, as well as being trained as critique research paper telephone counsellor.
She has written for a variety of online websites and blogs, but particularly enjoys focusing on health education and psychosocial issues.
See Educator Profile. This site complies with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information: Verify here. Log In Join Ausmed. Home Subscribe Teams Online CPD Latest Online CPD Learning Hubs Online Courses Video Lectures Guides to Practice Articles Explainers Podcasts Providers Why Ausmed? Documenting Compliance Learning Pricing Ausmed App Search CPD. Start my Subscription. Log In. Create Account. Online CPD Learning Hubs Online Courses Video Lectures Guides to Practice Critique research paper Explainers Podcasts Providers, critique research paper.
Online CPD Articles How to Critique a Research Article. Assign to staff. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. Keywords Three to six keywords critique research paper encapsulate the main topics of the research will have been drawn from the body of the article. Introduction This should include: Evidence of a literature review that is relevant and recent, critically appraising other works rather than merely describing them; Background information on the study to orientate the reader to the problem; Hypothesis or aims of the study; and Rationale for the study that justifies its need, i.
to explore an un-investigated gap in the literature. Materials and Methods Similar to a recipe, the description of materials and methods will allow others to replicate the study elsewhere if needed. Things to consider in this section are: What sort of sampling technique and size was used?
What proportion of the eligible sample participated? was the survey sent only in English? What were the strengths and weaknesses of the study? Were there threats to the reliability and validity of the study and were these controlled for? Were there any obvious biases? If a trial was undertaken, was it randomised, case controlled, blinded or double-blinded? Results Results should be statistically analysed and presented in a way that critique research paper average reader of the journal will understand.
Consider whether: There were any major omissions in the results, which could indicate bias; Percentages have been used to disguise small sample sizes; and The data generated is consistent with the data collected.
Discussion This should show insight into the meaning and significance of the research findings, critique research paper. Conclusions These should be clearly stated and will only be valid if the study was reliable, valid and used a representative sample size. References These should be relevant to the study, be up to date, critique research paper, and should provide a comprehensive list of citations within the text.
Final Thoughts Undertaking a critique of a research article may seem challenging at first, critique research paper, but will help you to evaluate whether the article has relevance to your own practice and workplace. Sarah Vogel Sarah Vogel specialises in producing well researched articles in the field of health and medicine. Help and Feedback Critique research paper Make a Content Suggestion Contact Us Company About Us Our Story The Team Ausmed for Teams Brand Guide CPD Guide.
Online CPD Latest CPD Online Courses Video Lectures Guides to Practice Articles Explainers Podcasts Learning Hubs All Topics All Resources Search. Features Overview Learning Smartphone App Partner With Ausmed 'Document CPD' Button Documentation Self-Care on Ausmed, critique research paper. Legals Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy Legals Position Statements.
How to Write the Academic Critique Assignment--Critique of Academic Journal Article
, time: 16:49How to Critique a Research Paper- Examples And Strategies
Future research on online orientation programs with a clear description of the program among a larger more diverse sample is necessary to provide evidence of the impact of online orientation programs. Summarize the key points of the article and your analysis. This closing sentence provides direction for future blogger.com Size: KB Table 1. Research questions - guidelines for critiquing a quantitative research study Elements influencing the beiievabiiity of the research Elements Writing styie Author Report titie Abstract Questions Is the report well written - concise, grammatically correct, avoid the Here is a really good example of a scholary research critique written by a student in EDRS The student who submitted this paper last semester earned a on his critique. The content of the paper is right on track. A succint summary is provided in the first paragraph
No comments:
Post a Comment